How Dividends Increase Return and Dampen Volatility

More and more academic research points toward a mostly efficient stock market, albeit not perfectly efficient. I therefore adopt the semi-strong efficient market hypothesis.
“Efficient” in this context means that stock prices accurately reflect the knowledge and expectations of all investors, and markets assemble and evaluate information so effectively that the price of a stock is usually the best estimate of its intrinsic value. Though prices are not always correct or perfect, markets are so competitive that it is unlikely any single investor can routinely profit at the expense of all other investors.
This means that technical analysis based on historical price movements is of little value to an investor. Picking “hot” stocks is a loser’s game without insider information--and that is illegal. The only reliable way to maximize return for risk is to eliminate underperforming inefficiencies in a portfolio and exploit the over-performing inefficiencies, or anomalies, which are few.
Sign up to receive other helpful email articles on retirement planning--free of charge
.
The College of Financial Planning in their investment curriculum have identified eight over-performing anomalies. The following four of the eight can be effectively used.
Dividend-yield anomaly Buy stocks with high dividend rates
Low P/E Low P/E stocks outperform high P/E stocks
Size effect Small-cap stocks outperform large cap stocks
BV/MV effect Stocks with high book to market prices outperform stocks with low book to market prices
Since the College’s assessment above, other factors such as quality and momentum have been identified, with momentum being the most difficult to implement effectively.
By using this information, the goal is to optimize stock allocations to produce higher returns without the equivalent addition of risk. Of course, there is no way of guaranteeing that these factors will continue to provide extra growth, but human behavior is in some way a constant that can perpetuate the same inefficiencies decade after decade.
The dividend yield anomaly allows investors to capture extra current income which can boost total return while reducing volatility. Professor Jeremy Siegel, author of Stocks for the Long Run and The Future for Investors , has done extensive back-testing and concludes that dividend-weighted indexes produce excess returns, and the long-term excess returns of domestic dividend-weighted indexes over capitalization-weighted indexes were almost identical to the difference in dividend yields between the indexes. In other words, the extra dividend yield gives the investor extra dollar-for-dollar total return. Wisdom Tree states the six reasons for using dividends to weight a stock portfolio:
a. Dividends provide a compelling theoretical basis for stock values
b. Dividends have historically provided the major part of the stock market’s real return
c. Dividends are an objective measure of company value independent of accounting schemes
d. Paying dividends indicates that management is focused on increasing shareholder value
e. Dividends are far more attractive today for taxable investors because of the recent legislation that lowered tax rates on qualifying dividends, and
f. Dividends dampen the volatility of an equity portfolio, as they are relatively stable and are not directly affected by market fluctuations
The third largest mutual fund company in America, American Funds , has developed a reputation for consistent returns and sound risk management by emphasizing dividends and dividend growth as an important part of their investment philosophy. As they say, “This approach has proved successful through bubbles, fads, and crashes.” No wonder they call dividend investing A 75-year-old “Fad ”.
Now there are many investment experts who argue that the so-called “dividend anomaly” is really explained by the newly-found quality anomaly. Because high-dividend stocks are often high-quality stocks, the growth premium was wrongly attributed to high dividends, when it was actually the q-factor. If this is true, screening for high- or growing-dividend stocks is still likely to capture this anomaly and increase your portfolio return, but it leaves out many equally good stocks that are high-quality but not high-dividend. (About 60% of U.S. stocks and about 40% of international stocks do not pay dividends.) Anti-dividend experts argue that a “total return” approach where you sell shares to create your own home-made dividends as you need them, is best. And if you want exposure to the growth factor that has been associated with high dividend stocks, choose high quality/profitability and value stocks instead.
Conclusion
I still think a high-dividend strategy can be effective for retirees seeking income from their portfolios. And with the momentum factor inherent in capitalization-weighted index funds, choosing dividend-weighted “smart-beta” funds can make a lot of sense for more risk-averse investors. Dividend-weighted funds can produce more income, dampen portfolio volatility, and avoid the over-weighting of pricey stocks. Most retirees find these three benefits highly desirable.


Travis Echols , CRPC®, CSA
Receive free Social Security Guide by email




Investment Advisory Services offered through JT Stratford, LLC. JT Stratford, LLC and Echols Financial Services, LLC are separate entities.








